Dürer's Chess

Back in 2003, I discovered the unique tiling of pentagons and diamonds first described the the German artist and mathematician Albrecht DÃ¼rer in 1525, and thought it would make a great board for a chess-like game. Knowing nothing about Zillions of Games programming at the time, I just jotted down a few basic ideas about piece movements (I thought of the SPIRE and the RINGMASTER at that time), and put the project on the shelf. After learning a little Zillions programming, I returned to the idea in January 2010, incorporating some of my original ideas, along with some borrowed from other variants.

There are four ways to capture pieces: displacement (as in FIDE and many other variants), assimilation (absorbing the powers of captured pieces, as well as friendly pieces through "mergers"), conversion, and sandwiching. See the Rules section for details.

Setup

Pieces

The pieces, except for Pawns, Guards, and the King, are grouped together in two "families". Please see the diagrams illustrating how they move.

Rules

There are four ways to make captures:

1. Displacement - enemy pieces that are not of the same "family" are simply removed from the board, as in FIDE and most other traditional varieties of Chess.

2. Assimilation - a piece may capture both friends and foes of the same "family" and assimilate their powers. The Rook (a sliding piece) may merge with a Ringmaster (also a slider) to form a Princess. It may not merge with, say, a Knight, because the Knight is not a slider.

Note that compound pieces formed this way may be split apart later. In the Zillions implementation, to break a Princess down into its components, simply click your mouse on the cell where you want the Rook-part or the Ringmaster-part to go. That part will move, leaving the other part behind. Fergus Duniho first popularized this method of capture in some of his games in the early 2000s.

3. Conversion - a leaping piece (Knight, Archer, Airman, Sailor, or any compound thereof) may convert an enemy piece to a friendly piece simply by flying over it and landing on the cell beyond. N.B. If the cell beyond is also occupied by an enemy piece, a leaper may make two captures simultaneously. For example, a Knight flying over an enemy Rook and landing on top of an enemy Spire would convert the former and kill the latter, in one move. An Archer flying over an enemy Ringmaster and landing on top of a Knight (either friend or foe) would simultaneously convert the Ringmaster and assimilate the Knight.

4. Sandwiching - Pawns and Guards also convert enemy pieces to friendly pieces, by "sandwiching." An enemy Knight caught between two friendly Pawns, for example, is converted to a friendly Knight. On rare occasions, Pawns and Guards may be able to capture two pieces simultaneously. There are three ways to win:

1. Checkmate.

2. Stalemate - I would like to make this better than a draw, but not quite as good as a checkmate. In tournaments, FIDE awards one point for a checkmate and a half-point to each player for a draw, with stalemate counting as a draw. For this game (and any others that I invent), I would award a half-point for a stalemate - but only to the player forcing the stalemate. I cannot implement this in the Zillions programme, as it does not differentiate between superior and inferior wins, so for the Zillions programme, a stalemate is a win.

3. Converson of the King - given that leaping pieces convert enemy pieces by flying over them, and that Pawns and Guards also convert enemy pieces by sandwiching, it is possible for the King to be converted to an enemy piece (this actually happened once while playtesting this game with Zillions). The player whose King defects to the enemy, of course, loses the game.

Notes

Piece values

Zillions of Games estimates that the pieces have the following values:

Guard - 6448 (0.75 pawns); Pawn - 8522; Archer - 6071 (0.7 pawns); Airman - 19365 (2.3 pawns); Sailor - 8571 (1.0 pawns); Knight - 11481 (1.3 pawns); Spire - 9945 (1.7 pawns); Warlord - 29919 (3.5 pawns); Ringmaster - 35562 (4.1 pawns); Rook - 37657 (4.4 pawns).

Zillions estimates the compound pieces' worth as about 1.8 times the sum of their parts. I personally disagree with this. By way of comparison, the FIDE Queen is worth about 1.2-1.3 times the combined values of its component pieces, the Rook and Bishop. I would therefore expect compound pieces in this game to be worth more than the sum of their parts, but not excessively so. Assigning values to pieces is not an exact science, however; even experts disagree about the relative value of the pieces in FIDE chess, and the value assigned to the Queen by Zillions (7.7 pawns) is less than what most experts estimate.

In this game, I think the Warlord and Knight are much more powerful on pentagons than on diamonds, but the program does not recognize the distinction. The Warlord and Knight are, in my opinion, overvalued on diamonds and undervalued on pentagons (which does affect decisions made when it comes to exchanging pieces).

I also disagree with the Zillions valuing of the Archer less than a Pawn. In terms of passive movement (which I think is the only one that Zillions takes account of), that estimate would be correct. But an Archer can both capture enemy pieces and merge with friendly pieces, assimilating their powers; a Pawn cannot. An Archer can also convert an enemy piece to a friendly piece by flying over it; a Pawn needs to work with another Pawn to "sandwich" an enemy piece to do that. An Archer can make two captures simultaneously; a Pawn cannot. I will continue to explore ways to tweak the piece values.

Despite the inherent subjectivity of Zillions estimates, I think they are good as a rough guide.

Play DÃ¼rer's Chess!

I have programmed a Zillions of Games file to play this game. You may download it here. You need the Zillions of Games engine installed to play it.

This 'user submitted' page is a collaboration between the posting user and the Chess Variant Pages. Registered contributors to the Chess Variant Pages have the ability to post their own works, subject to review and editing by the Chess Variant Pages Editorial Staff.

By David Cannon.
Web page created: 2010-02-15. Web page last updated: 2010-07-13

Comments

Dürer's Chess. Dürer's Chess, played on a board of 151 tessellating pentagons and diamonds. (Cells: 151)

💡📝David Cannon wrote on Sun, May 1, 2011 07:09 PM EDT:

I don't know what's causing the problem - maybe it's my own server. All I know is that whenever I try to download, a window pops open asking for your password. But never mind - I also found some of your games on the Zillions website. I've downloaded a few by now and am studying them:-) I think I've got the general idea figured out now, so you'll see an update here soon. Thanks a lot!

M Winther wrote on Fri, Apr 29, 2011 11:56 AM EDT:

I don't understand why you can't download. Other people have downloaded.
/Mats

💡📝David Cannon wrote on Fri, Apr 29, 2011 05:58 AM EDT:

Thanks to Mats and Nicholas. Mats, I tried to look at your games, but when I tried to download them, a box popped up asking for your password!

M Winther wrote on Fri, Apr 29, 2011 02:45 AM EDT:

It is very easy to tweak piece values. You create one or more invisible squares outside the board, and fill them with empty pieces (either of a neutral party, or an equal amount of black and white dummy-pieces). Then you make an add to these squares, but first you must verify that it's empty: 
(define tweak-shift ( $1 (verify empty?) add))

These extra adds  must be placed outside the normal move type, so that they get a lower priority (to avoid that Zillions wastes time on them). The more adds you make to these external squares, the higher is the piece value. If you need to lower the piece value, you must increase the piece value in all the others. When increasing the general piece value of all pieces, the queen must have most adds, and the pawns need only a few, perhaps only one extra add. Have a look in any of my implementations:
http://hem.passagen.se/melki9/chessvar.htm
/Mats

Nicholas Wolff wrote on Fri, Apr 29, 2011 01:40 AM EDT:

I know there is a way to tweak the piece values, as you said you wanted to do with the archer and pawns in your rules, but I don't know the ZoG programming language well enough to tell you how. I have seen a few games do it. If I recall (and I may be wrong), try either Catapults of Troy or Fugue. I think those at least one of those two .zrf files has examples on how to do it. Hope that helps!