Enter Your Reply

Score: (1) Bifurcators > Great Shatranj > Mastodon > Three Player > (5) Unicorn Great > Big Board > Sissa > Eurasian > Schoolbook > (10) Bilateral > Centennial > Kings Court > Wildebeest > Fantasy Grand > (15) Black Ghost > Eight-Stone > Modern > Melee > Templar > (20) Courier de la Dama > Switching > (22) Seirawan. [Next up: Fischer Random Chess. Where would you place it?] Notice the trenchant style in Bilateral before artwork predominated in the Chess Variant Page: http://www.chessvariants.org/large.dir/bilateral-chess.html. Eurasian (Feb. 2003) and Bilateral (Sept. 2002) have comparable piece-type modelled from Xiangqi Cannon, but Eurasian splits them up, as Dawson originally did: http://www.chessvariants.org/large.dir/eurasian.html, where the diagonal counterpart Vao is colourbound. Despite keeping the centre intact, Bilateral becomes more Track Two than One, like Eight-Stone does here. The query ''Why should the Cannon move Rook-wise and not Bishop-wise?,'' leads to the designer's creating the excellent new flip piece-type. With only Lion and Cannon/Canon on 8x10 instead, omitting Bilateral's Elephant and Wizard, this CV would rank higher -- like was attempted with Centennial. Cannon/Canon may ultimately be preferable to higher-ranked Sissa and the Eurasian paired piece-types of same mode, if Bilateral were only re-embodied. That need for revision conveniently places Bilateral right above Centennial in the same boat. Bilateral is the first add-on CV not nominated in 2008. There were no new additions in year 2009 whatsoever. Any suggestions of important omissions in 2010 are welcome. Bias is towards greater than 8x8 in the project ongoing. The rankings establish a baseline. By design, the higher-ranked are intended to be harder to change their ordering, and lower-ranked easier even to dis-lodge from the list of approval altogether.