Proof for who is right or wrong has to be collected. So far we have only seen that kanji tiles are no good for westerners. Would Japanese do better? I doubt it, but that is not proof. That the kanji are small is a feeble excuse: they must be smaller as a consequence of tiles being drawn around them. Which I claimed to be a bad idea, as it that unavoidably leaves less space. That there are now complaints about this smallnes sort of confirms that.
Upside-down pictograms would be better for westerners? Well, you can try that here. (Prepare for disaster!)
Proof for who is right or wrong has to be collected. So far we have only seen that kanji tiles are no good for westerners. Would Japanese do better? I doubt it, but that is not proof. That the kanji are small is a feeble excuse: they must be smaller as a consequence of tiles being drawn around them. Which I claimed to be a bad idea, as it that unavoidably leaves less space. That there are now complaints about this smallnes sort of confirms that.
Upside-down pictograms would be better for westerners? Well, you can try that here. (Prepare for disaster!)